I haven’t completely lost my mind, or changed my opinion on the value of web analytics. Instead, I just think you need to be careful. My warning is simple: Web Analytics can suck the life from your content.
If you have a combination of niche content and mainstream content (say you write a blog about music) if you only listen to analytics, you will kill your site. The web is built upon a foundation of availability of all types of content. Naturally mainstream content is searched for more than niche content, and you may see more pageviews for you mainstream content. It may not event be mainstream, it may just be your most popular content. The point is you can’t let the popular content become the only thing on your site.
Why not? Why not just make your site focused on the popular? A few reasons really, 1: niche content will be easier to win in the competition for traffic (even if it comes from a smaller pie) 2: Saturation makes the web dull - and 3: I don’t like it.
Lesson: don’t just blog about apple and google… it’s really boring.